‘Pinoy Dream Academy’ threatens ‘Philippine Idol’s’ lead
WHEN ABC-5 announced that it had gotten permission from the “American Idol” franchise to produce the hit singing search’s local counterpart, the channel won important plus points with viewers.
The feat was a feather in its cap, and caused the relatively new channel to upstage the major TV networks, due to the popularity of the original US show.
Franchising coup
Of course, the majors couldn’t be expected to take the franchising coup on the chin without trying to neutralize it.
Thus, it was no surprise when ABS-CBN in turn announced that it was developing its own franchise-based search for outstanding young singers, to be titled “Pinoy Dream Academy.”
Instead of fast-tracking the start of the competition proper of its “Philippine Idol” show, however, ABC-5 continued to bide its time, telecasting a detailed coverage of its initial audition phases.
Despite its advantage in terms of time, it, in effect, allowed “Dream Academy” to catch up. So, as of this writing, we now have the strange spectacle of “Philippine Idol” still to announce its final 12 bets, while on Aug. 26, “Dream Academy” will start its contest proper after choosing its 16 scholars from 38 semifinalists.
More popular
Of course, the “Idol” franchise is more popular than the locally unseen and untested “Academy” format, so ABC-5 still has the advantage.
But, Channel 2’s “Academy” format could in time prove to be even more viewable, because it combines its talent-search element with the “in-house” factor made popular locally by “Pinoy Big Brother.”
In other words, viewers could get more personally involved with the “Academy’s” singers because they would not just be seeing them perform, but also getting to know them really well as people, as they view them living in the Academy’s house
The format of the Pinoy Dream Academy is more appealing to mass audiences. Pinoy Big Brother has gained so much popularity that success is almost proven. Personally, I still prefer the Idol Format because eventually, a star needs to garner popularity. This can be gauged through text voting. Maybe Pinoy Dream Academy has text voting too.